Lifting deed restrictions on rural property

by Daniele
(Anderson Alabama)

Visitor Question: I want to buy a piece of property in metes and bounds in the country. There are now three tracts: (1) 32 acres of woods, (2) 12 acres cleared with a barn , and (3) 1 acre with a house. These are to be purchased all together.

I have just learned the previous owner restricted the deed with no pigs, no chickens, no timber to be cut and no building to be erected on a specific area. I went to the previous owner to see if he would lift these and he said no. Is there any way to have them removed anyway?

Editors Reply: Probably not, we're afraid.

A deed restriction is imposed by an owner and can only be lifted through actions that are described either in the document that created the restriction, or in local or more frequently state law.

You could check with an attorney in Alabama to see if there is any time limitation on the amount of time that a deed restriction remains valid. In many states, a deed restriction is valid in perpetuity or until very stringent conditions are met (such as every single property owner in a subdivision agreeing to the change, for example).

Most states now have their statutes online, so you might be able to do the research yourself to see if state law addresses this issue.

The most common situation is that state law allows the deed restriction to remain in place unless the person creating the restriction wants to lift it. Since you say you approached the current owner, whom you say created this provision, you probably do not have any recourse.

In this case, since the person who created the situation is living and known to you, your best bet would be to try to change the course of the negotiation. You could offer more money to see if money talks in this particular situation.

You can try to figure out why they wanted the deed restriction. For instance, did they want to protect beloved neighbors from what some might consider to be an aggravation? Did they think that chickens on the site would change the soil conditions in a negative way? Were they just environmentalists who didn't want to see timber cut? Did the current owner's parents have these particular opinions and preferences, and the owner is just being loyal to a family memory?

For instance, some farm families just think pigs are "dirty" animals and don't like to see them on the property. The sum of these conditions makes it seem as though the current owner is a purist of some sort on what proper use of agricultural land may be.

If you can learn the motivation behind the restriction, you will be in a much better position to try to negotiate a satisfactory deal.

Your situation is unusual in that often prospective buyers cannot locate and talk with the people who created the restrictive covenant, either because the original author is long deceased or no longer able to talk with buyers.

Although it won't be the answer you want to hear from us, our bet is that you will be unable to reach an agreement with this property owner that will allow you to either live with the restriction or convince this owner to lift it entirely. But we wish you the best of luck in trying to do so.

For the rest of our visitors, by the way, "metes and bounds" is simply a system of writing a legal description of a property that isn't legally subdivided. It is common in rural areas and also in larger tracts within an urban area that have never been divided. But that factor is irrelevant to the answer to the question.

Comments for Lifting deed restrictions on rural property

Click here to add your own comments

Restrictions on rural property
by: Anonymous

Our property is in rural area in Langston. It's not a subdivision and not in an HOA. It's just land in the country. Three or four property owners don't want to abide by the restrictions and the person who put them on the land doesn't enforce them. Can we get them taken off?

Editors Reply: This depends on exactly how the deed restrictions were written, when they were written, law, and case law in your state.

However, as a generalization, in your case it seems like the person who imposed the restrictions is still alive. If so, act promptly to talk with that person and explain the situation. We suggest talking with all of your neighbors beforehand, if possible, so that you can present a united front to the original owner of the land. If that person agrees, he or she will need to consult an attorney about the proper way to remove the restrictions. If you think it will help, all of you together might offer to pay that person's legal fees.

Just have a good tight rationale when you talk with the original owner, and you might have a good chance of success. What you don't want to do is procrastinate and then have to deal with heirs who don't care about your situation and can't be bothered.

Simple form applicable to lifting deed restriction
by: charles beasley

It appears there is no form on line free or paid that the a Buyer and Seller may use to lift a deed restriction. The restriction was placed on two lots where they may not be sold separately. The buyer and seller agree that the restriction is of no use. It was put there by a lawyer arbitrarily. Now I have to get to a lawyer to get it off. The seller has agreed that he never authorized it to be placed on the property.

Editors Comment: Yes, it seems that it should be simple, but it isn't. This is one of the big reasons we aren't a fan of deed restrictions unless they are very well thought out.

Similar Reason Why We Don't Have Property in That Area
by: Anonymous

Funny thing is I have run across the same issue with several properties in that area. It has stopped us from buying there. A big one is no mobile homes, which is funny since they can cost as much if not more than a conventional home.

Like in your case, I can understand that the previous owner would want to restrict the chicken and pig farms which are rampant in the area and are truly ruining the countryside. Also, to an extent not cutting the timber (since the trees are being cut at an alarming rate and being replaced with pine tree farms). This may have a lot to do with neighbors who are possibly family members or lifelong friends.

But I don't understand the restrictions on where a house can be built. What does the previous owner care? That would worry me.

All in all, if you want to control what happens on the property after you sell it maybe you have too much emotional attachment and shouldn't sell it at all.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to HOA and Deed Restrictions Questions.

Join GOOD COMMUNITY PLUS, which provides you monthly with short features or tips about timely topics for neighborhoods, towns and cities, community organizations, and rural or small town environments. Unsubscribe any time. Give it a try.